Ripple CTO Emeritus: BIP-110 Vote Loss Doesn’t Justify New Chain
David Schwartz, the Ripple CTO emeritus, argued on August 31 that supporters of Bitcoin’s BIP-110 fork crossed from governance into an attack after rejecting the soft-fork result and continuing on a separate proof-of-work chain.
His exchange with fork supporter captures the dispute: whether losing a consensus fight justifies creating a new Bitcoin chain, or whether that move itself amounts to attacking the network.
New Chain Goes Live
“You’re not ‘still’ attacking,” Schwartz wrote in response to the take. “You switched from participating in governance to attacking when you refused to accept that you lost.”
“I’m not arguing that you are incapable of pretending you have good faith disagreement over governance,” the XRP Ledger architect added. “I’m arguing that there’s lots of evidence that when you do so, you are pretending.”
The chain he referenced went live through a flag-day hard fork at block 961,640, replacing SHA256d with BLAKE2b as the mining algorithm. The update also introduced a new 164-byte block header and temporary rules capping block size at roughly 300 kilobytes until September 2027.
Bitcoin Knots developer Luke Dashjr defended the switch on August 30, arguing that BLAKE2b carries none of SHA256d’s known weaknesses, such as ASICBoost, and that the redesigned header closes a block-withholding loophole that previously relied on miner monitoring to catch.
A Fork That Struggled Before It Split Again
As reported previously, the BIP-110 chain split from Bitcoin’s main chain at block 961,632 after failing to draw enough miner support.
The backing pool, Roughnecks, produced only two blocks before the branch stalled while the main chain kept its normal pace, and the gap between them grew to several hundred blocks within weeks. Dashjr was separately removed as an editor of Bitcoin’s improvement proposal repository over what was described as a conflict of interest in his handling of BIP-110.
The dispute traces back to Bitcoin Core dropping its old limit on OP_RETURN data, which let more non-monetary content, including Ordinals and Runes, fill blocks that BIP-110 supporters wanted reserved for payments.
Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.
You may also like
New York Fed warns: Service sector input and sales prices surge, significant price pressure
A survey by the New York Federal Reserve shows that service sector input costs and prices in October rose sharply, while the business activity index fell to its lowest level since March. Businesses have turned pessimistic about the outlook, with increasing inflation and interest rate pressures.
Boeing (BA.US) Max 10 certification expected to be announced next week, adding new leverage for debt relief
The Boeing 737 Max 10 has completed key certification meetings and could be approved as early as next week. As Boeing's largest variant to rival Airbus, this model will help airlines replace aging 757s and is expected to become a cash cow for Boeing to reduce its debt.
Foreign holdings of US Treasuries rebounded in August, with UK holdings surpassing $1 trillion for the first time
In August, foreign holdings of U.S. Treasury bonds increased by over 83 billions USD, with Canada and Belgium leading the increase; meanwhile, holdings by Japan and China continued to decline to multi-year lows, and for the first time, the UK's holdings surpassed 1 trillion USD.
Strive's bitcoin holdings increased to 35,595, and TD Cowen raised its target price to $56.
Crypto prices
More
